Week 12 College Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Playoff lineup advice from Eric Froton

Week 12 College Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Playoff lineup advice from Eric Froton

Eric Froton Fantasy Analyst Thu, November 19, 2026 at 7:52 PM UTC · 12 min read About Our Ads Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement College fantasy football playoffs are here, and with them brings a series of tough lineup decisions that can make or break your season. Every lineup choice is under a microscope, so here are my start/sit calls for Week 12. Good luck!

Arizona's all-time leading passer, Fifita has had his finest season to date completing 71.7% of his passes at 9.6 yards per attempt. He's having his finest season from a fantasy perspective, averaging 25.4 PPG and ranking ninth in total points scored at the position. The fifth-year signal-caller has thrown for 280+ yards in eight straight appearances while cashing in 2+ touchdowns in seven of those contests. His opponent this week, Kansas State, is 2-6 versus Power Four teams and has been relentlessly attacked vertically, averaging 9.2 air yards per target (128th) with 18.5% of completions gaining 20+ yards (110th). With Arizona ranking 12th nationally in SP+ offense averaging 6.5 yards per play, Fifita should once again clear the 25-point mark and is well worth starting in the first week of the playoffs.

Iowa State has looked reborn, averaging 41 points over the last three games, with Raynor scoring 29+ points in two of those contests. His balanced rushing/passing profile offers a stable floor against UCF's leaky secondary that ranks 109th in explosive pass rate and allows 6.8 yards per dropback (108th).

Kansas is 2-6 against P4 opponents and allows explosive pass plays 18.5% of the time (110th). Bachmeier has scored 27+ points in four of his last six appearances and should have little trouble dicing up the Jayhawks' secondary that ranks 126th in havoc rate.

Hill has taken over the primary rushing duties since Jordon Davison went down with a lower leg injury that will cause him to miss a third straight game. Despite facing two excellent defenses in Ohio State and Michigan over the last two weeks, Hill thrived, scoring 24.6 and 21.2 points as the increased workload (39 touches in total) directly translated into fantasy production. Since replacement QB Dylan Raiola has settled into the starting role, the Ducks have rattled off three straight victories and face a Michigan State defense which ranks 102nd in rushing success rate (44.6%) and 94th allowing 33.4 yards per drive. Hill's roster rate has shot up to 86% and he's a locked-in starter for as long as Davison is out of action for the resurgent Ducks.

The Mack Daddy generated substantial preseason buzz in a competitive ASU running back room, which hinted at the true freshman taking over the starting job from Kyson Brown at some point in the season.

Mack didn't officially wrest control of the backfield until Week 8, when he ripped Kansas State for 26 carries, 159 yards and four touchdowns for a career-high 41.1 points. He has recorded at least 15+ points in five of his last six games and has received 27 red zone carries, which he converted into six touchdowns. Mack (5'10"/215 lbs) runs with a punishing style and refuses to avoid contact, instead preferring to lower the boom and pancake would-be tacklers.

The Sun Devils play an Oklahoma State defense that allowed 50+ points to both Iowa State and Texas Tech over the last three weeks, and allows 5.8 yards per play (98th) with 7.6% of plays generating 20+ yards (121st). I expect ASU to ply Mack with 26+ touches for the fifth straight game, which should result in another 20+ point performance this Saturday.

A true heavy-usage workhorse, Ford is averaging 31.5 PPG with 24+ touches in each of his last four games. He should once again erupt for 20+ points against a reeling Cal defense that ranks 121st in yards per carry.

One of the most intriguing late-season risers at the RB position, Young is coming off two games with 20+ points in his last three appearances, and faces an absolutely pitiful Cincinnati defense that just allowed 46.9 fantasy points to ISU star Aiden Flora. He's a strong flex play versus the Bearcats' struggling defensive front that ranks 123rd in rushing success rate.

Arguably the most explosive receiver in the country, Malachi Toney caught an astounding 86% of his 85 targets before sustaining an ankle injury that will sideline him for the remainder of the regular season. His absence opens the door for Duke transfer Barkate to take over as the primary aerial weapon, and he has excelled catching 84% of his targets while putting up 22 points against the elite Notre Dame secondary and securing eight receptions for a season-high 134 yards last week versus his former team, Duke. He should be a fixture in CFF lineups against a Virginia Tech defense that ranks 113th nationally in wide open target rate (28%) and and 106th in adjusted net yards per pass attempt (9.0).

Mosley joins the likes of freshman phenom WRs Jesse Legree and Legend Glasker in having captured the admiration of the CFB watching public with their highlight-reel worthy receiving acumen. He started his collegiate career with two, 100-yard performances before suffering an injury in Week 3 that kept him out for a month. Since returning, Mosley has recorded 17+ points and 100+ yards in four of his last five contests, including a nine reception, 130-yard showing against Indiana's second ranked defense. USC lines up against a Maryland program in transition after firing HC Mike Locksley, ranking 106th in points per drive with a 71% adjusted completion rate allowed. Mosley is a top-10 starting option this week and is a must-start versus a floundering Terps' secondary.

Pitt has one of the most bankable imbalance defenses in the P4, ranking first nationally allowing 3.3 yards per carry, but ranking 127th allowing wide open targets on 31% of throws while allowing 16.3 yards per successful dropback (123rd). Richardson is a speed demon who should catch a long touchdown from QB Lincoln Kienholz.

Sowell has quietly been the engine of Penn State's pass game after WR Koby Howard went down with a season-ending injury. He should score 15+ points for the fourth time in the last six games against a Rutgers defense that is one of the worst three defenses in all of P4 football.

The Ohio State transfer has been as consistently productive as any tight end in the country, putting up 10+ points and 50+ yards in six of his last seven contests. Thurman has established himself as UNC's unquestioned red-zone maven, receiving 18 targets, catching 10 for a whopping seven red-zone scores. He has caught at least five passes in six of his last seven games, and should have success once again versus a UVA defense that ranks 98th in explosive completion rate and 121st with 55% of completions gaining first down yardage. Arguably the most projectable and safest player among all P4 tight ends, Thurman should be active and in your lineup.

Similar to his teammate Barkate, Lofton has seen an uptick in targets and production since Toney went down. He has an enticing matchup against a Virginia Tech defense that just allowed Stanford TE Benji Blackburn to lead the Cardinal in receiving with 63 yards in a 40-22 blowout of the Hokies last week.

SMU is in the midst of its toughest two-game stretch of the season, and failed the first test in spectacular fashion by getting eviscerated 49-7 by Wake Forest last weekend. Jennings was totally flummoxed by the Demon Deacons' secondary, producing just 10.9 points and continuing a troubling trend where he has scored 24+ points just once in six of his last seven games against P4 foes. His lack of rushing potency has really suppressed Jennings' fantasy upside, and he now has to face Notre Dame's top flight secondary that ranks seventh in yards per dropback (4.9) and ninth in explosive completion rate allowed. I simply cannot trust the immobile pocket distributor on the road against a legitimate national title contender in Notre Dame.

Leavitt had a good run against the lower echelon defenses of the SEC, but he has been bottled up by Alabama and Texas, scoring 15.8 and 14.5 points in the last two weeks. He now has to face a Tennessee secondary that ranks third in air yards per target (5.4) and yards per dropback allowed (4.6), while pitching three-and-outs 44.6% of the time (1st in FBS). Don't risk your playoff life on Leavitt's interception-prone arm.

Raymond was one of my most prominent "fades" of the preseason after he was so volume reliant in order to be productive last year, leaning on his 244 carries to fuel his 20.5 PPG average. However, Rutgers' dismal 125th-ranked defense is statistically the second-worst defense among all P4 programs and puts the RU offense at a major disadvantage, leading to extremely pass-tilted game scripts. For his part, Raymond has eclipsed the 13-point barrier just one time in his last six appearances, with a combined 10.3 points generated over the last two games in which Rutgers scored just 10 total points. He faces a Penn State defense that ranks 10th in three-and-out rate (39%) and 23rd in rushing success rate allowed (37%), with all the factors mentioned leaving me to believe Raymond will once again disappoint fantasy managers who rely on him to bring home a playoff-winning performance this weekend.

The Mustangs were thoroughly dominated by Wake Forest by a score of 49-7, with Raphael converting 15 carries into a mere 54 yards. Raphael's ceiling for this game is 12 points, meaning you cannot rely on him in a playoff scenario.

An undersized rusher who is known for his big-play ability, Brown has not received the volume the CFF community expected after managing just 36 yards on 16 carries versus Ole Miss in Week 1. He has scored under 14 points in three of his last four, and plays a Pitt defense that will let you throw all day on them, as discussed earlier, but smothers the run game allowing a mere 0.8 yards before contact (1st in FBS).

Roebuck was the preseason favorite to replace departed Washington WR1 Denzel Boston, with Rashid Williams also receiving favorable press for his play in fall camp. I had the opportunity to watch Roebuck play against UCLA last year, when he popped catching 7-of-10 passes for 96 yards and a touchdown. He has been pounded with 90 targets this season and had a nice midseason run where he scored 15+ points in four-of-five games. However, over his last three appearances that production has fallen off, with Roebuck producing just 81 receiving yards and a touchdowns in that timeframe.

It appears that he has fallen behind WR Chris Lawson in the pecking order, as Lawson has scored in double digits in each of his last six games, with 20+ points in three of those contests. Compounding matters is a ferocious Indiana defense that ranks second nationally and allows just 1.1 points per drive (4th), and Roebuck sporting an ankle injury that will assuredly slow him down if he's able to suit up. With a diminishing role and an injury slowing him down, I'm benching Roebuck in favor of Lawson.

Oregon WR Jeremiah McClellan got hurt early in the year after erupting for 150 yards and a touchdown in Week 1 versus Boise State, looking like he was ready to emerge as the Ducks' WR2 alongside Dak Moore. Stewart was very productive early in the season, but has failed to score 10+ points since Week 6 versus UCLA. I fear Stewart is now the fourth option with McClellan's return, meaning you cannot put him in your lineup.

Trying to figure out which games Faison will be fantasy relevant has been a weekly game of Whack-A-Mole. He has failed to hit the 10.0 point mark in five of his last eight appearances, and Notre Dame could simply decide to bulldoze the inferior SMU defensive line, which clouds Faison's profile this week. I am staying away this week.

Pittman has been splitting work with TE Theo Ohrstrom, and just popped off for five receptions for 76 yards in a pass-heavy situation, where SMU was defeated 49-7 by Wake Forest. Prior to Saturday, Pittman had scored just 9.5 total points over the previous three games, and now has to play Notre Dame's top flight secondary that ranks seventh nationally in yards per dropback allowed (4.9) and 114th in QBR. With Ohrstrom providing internal competition catching 18 passes for 217 yards and four touchdowns, in addition to facing Notre Dame's smothering secondary, I am sitting Pittman this week and think he regresses after a rare boom week versus the Demon Deacons.

The Bears have fired their HC Dave Aranda, and just got embarrassed by BYU, averaging just 4.3 yards per attempt for 238 total yards versus the Cougars. For his part Livingston took a step back by failing to secure either of his targets. The Red Raiders rank second in FBS with an 8.6% linebacker havoc rate, and 14th in suppressing explosive pass plays. Livingston is a product of his offense, which may or may not be able to move the ball on Tech. Don't take the chance, leave Livingston on the bench.


Source: Sports

Post a Comment

0 Comments